ClickToFit
ClickToFit
Manufacturing · Facts · Process chains

Champion: Advocating J+G Internally

New production aids rarely catch on by themselves. Anyone who advocates internally for a new approach to fixtures, grippers or transport protection needs answers to the usual objections – and a pilot case that convinces with figures from their own plant rather than brochure values.

Typical objections – and an honest answer

Every objection has a kernel of truth. The convincing approach is to acknowledge it and show what is checked in the specific case.

ObjectionWhat is trueWhat you should check
“Plastic is not stable enough.”For many gripper jaws, locating fixtures and gauges, engineering plastics such as polyamide are sufficient. Lighter fingers also reduce the load on robots and axes.Forces, lever arms, continuous load and temperature. For high continuous load or abrasion: metal, inserts or replaceable wear inserts.
“That is too expensive per piece.”For high-volume parts this is true – then a tooling-based process is the right choice. For one-offs and variants, however, tool making is eliminated entirely.Choose the route by quantity (Manufacturing strategy) and compare total costs: design, assembly, waiting time, downtime.
“It is not reproducible.”Same file, same material, same process: the processes at FIT are validated and subject to quality control.Define functional dimensions and verify them on the part. Tight fits are post-machined or solved with inserts.
“Printed rubber does not last.”Often true: printed rubber-like materials do not match true elastomers.After testing, produce soft parts such as pads and plugs as elastomer or vacuum-cast parts – FIT does both.
“Not approved for food.”There are additive materials with declarations of conformity for food contact.This applies per material, processing and application – not across the board. Clarify conformity in writing before ordering; consider surface finish and cleaning.
“We already have CNC machines.”Correct – for simple geometries, milling often remains the best solution.Additive pays off for contours, channels, lightweight design and variants. Best combined: frame and datums made conventionally, the contour printed.
“It takes a long time until it is available.”Without tooling, tool making is eliminated; a change is a new file.Lead time depends on the process, rework and capacity utilisation. The date in the quote is binding.

How to set up the pilot case

1
Choose one part
A production aid with a known problem: too heavy, too many variants, scratches on the workpiece, plugs that do not fit.
2
Document the current state
Costs, waiting time, weight, setup time, downtime – figures from your own plant.
3
Part check
Upload the CAD file and describe the application; FIT will get back to you with an assessment.
4
Sample in use
Test the part under real conditions – using the same metrics as before.
5
Present the result
Before and after side by side, limits stated openly. The decision on the next parts follows from this.

What makes a decision convincing

  • One part instead of ten. A successful pilot is more convincing than a long list of candidates.
  • Your own figures. Weight, setup time or waiting time from your own plant carry more weight than values from brochures.
  • State the limits. Whoever says where milling remains cheaper is taken seriously on everything else.
  • Involve everyone early. Design, maintenance, quality assurance and purchasing each see different risks.
  • Put a sample in their hands. A part on the table explains more than a presentation.
← Case examplesHave your part checked →