ClickToFit
ClickToFit
Manufacturing · Facts · Process chains

When Additive J+G Does Not Fit

Additively manufactured production aids solve many problems – but not every one. These are the cases in which a different route is better, with a guide value and rationale. Often the answer is not “do not print at all,” but “print only part of it” or “print first, then cast in series.”

At a glance

CaseDifficult fromBetter
Simple geometryPlate, angle bracket, spacer – anything that can be drawn in 2DLaser-cut blank, bent part, milling; print only the contour (hybrid)
Consumable parts in large quantitiesfrom about 1,000 identical partsElastomer production, injection moulding with additive tooling, vacuum casting
True rubber propertiesSealing effect, recovery, abrasion over many cyclesInjection-moulded or pressed elastomer, PU by vacuum casting
Tight datums in the printed partPositioning tolerance well below ±0.1 % of the lengthInsert index pins and bushings, mill or ream datums
Continuous load, clamping force and heatPlastic under constant clamping force or warm over a longer periodLoad path through metal (inserts, purchased parts), filled plastics, metal printing
Larger than the build envelopebeyond the build envelope, e.g. SAF 315 × 208 × 293 mmHybrid: profile frame and laser-cut plate, print only the locating fixtures
Too thin for the loadWalls below 0.7 mm (SLS, SLA), 1 mm (FDM), 0.5 mm (PolyJet)Dimension wall thickness according to load, ribs instead of thin surfaces
Sensitive visible surfaces on the workpieceContact with Class A surfacesSoft pads (elastomer, vacuum casting), smooth processes, rework
CertificationsFood, pharma, cleanroom, ESDSelect a material with certification – clarify in writing before ordering

Figures according to fit.technology, Additive plastic processes and fit.technology, Conventional processes; worked examples derived from them.

Simple geometry

Plate, angle bracket, spacer – anything that can be drawn in 2D

A laser-cut blank or a bent sheet-metal part costs a fraction, is stiffer and is dimensionally accurate immediately. Printing offers no advantage here.

Better suited: Laser-cut blank, bent part, milling; print only the contour (hybrid)

Consumable parts in large quantities

from about 1,000 identical parts

Transport plugs, caps and clips are consumed. From the quantity a tool is designed for (injection moulding 1,000–50,000, elastomer 1,000–100,000 pieces per tool), tooled parts are cheaper and have better properties. In between lies vacuum casting with 15–500 parts per mould.

Better suited: Elastomer production, injection moulding with additive tooling, vacuum casting

True rubber properties

Sealing effect, recovery, abrasion over many cycles

Printed rubber-like materials (e.g. TPU) are sufficient for samples. According to FIT, elastomer parts have “significantly better properties than additively manufactured, rubber-like materials.”

Better suited: Injection-moulded or pressed elastomer, PU by vacuum casting

Tight datums in the printed part

Positioning tolerance well below ±0.1 % of the length

Even accurate printing processes achieve about ±0.1 % (PolyJet according to FIT) – on 300 mm that is ±0.3 mm. Bores for dowel pins and stops with functional dimensions belong in metal.

Better suited: Insert index pins and bushings, mill or ream datums

Continuous load, clamping force and heat

Plastic under constant clamping force or warm over a longer period

Plastic creeps: under continuous load it slowly yields, and faster when warm. A clamping point that holds today can have play after weeks.

Better suited: Load path through metal (inserts, purchased parts), filled plastics, metal printing

Larger than the build envelope

beyond the build envelope, e.g. SAF 315 × 208 × 293 mm

Larger parts must be split and joined; every joint costs accuracy. Large volumes also make printing expensive, even though most surfaces do not need a contour.

Better suited: Hybrid: profile frame and laser-cut plate, print only the locating fixtures

Too thin for the load

Walls below 0.7 mm (SLS, SLA), 1 mm (FDM), 0.5 mm (PolyJet)

These are manufacturing limits according to FIT, not design values. Anything that has to absorb a gripping force needs a multiple of that.

Better suited: Dimension wall thickness according to load, ribs instead of thin surfaces

Sensitive visible surfaces on the workpiece

Contact with Class A surfaces

SLS surfaces are grainy at Ra ~13 µm (according to FIT) and can discolour or leave pressure marks. SLA is at Ra ~2 µm.

Better suited: Soft pads (elastomer, vacuum casting), smooth processes, rework

Certifications

Food, pharma, cleanroom, ESD

Conformity applies per material, process and application. Without certification the production aid must not be used, no matter how well it fits.

Better suited: Select a material with certification – clarify in writing before ordering
← Manufacturing strategyCost-effectiveness →Have your part checked →